In Which Order Should I Read Allen Eskens Books?

Few things feel better than finding a mystery writer who treats their setting and characters like real, living neighbors. If you’ve ever picked up a psychological thriller only to feel like the characters were just cardboard pieces moving through a plot, switching over to Allen Eskens is going to feel like an absolute revelation.

Eskens writes with an incredible sense of human empathy, likely pulled from his decades working as a real-life criminal defense attorney. Instead of churning out completely disconnected, formulaic procedurals, he has done something brilliant: he has crafted a series of standalone mystery novels that slowly weave together into one giant, interconnected community map set in Minnesota and Missouri. A major character in one book might show up as a side investigator, a grieving brother, or a defense lawyer in the next.

Because his books share a collective soul, jumping in blindly can cause you to miss major character growth or accidentally spoil previous plot twists. Let’s map out the ultimate reading order so you can experience this literary tapestry exactly the way it was meant to be read.

The Master Community Order: Chronological & Publication Path

Though Eskens groups his characters into smaller arcs—like the Joe Talbert cases, the Max Rupert investigations, and Boady Sanden’s legal battles—they all cross over seamlessly. Following them in strict publication order is by far the most satisfying route because you grow alongside this small community organically.

Here is the complete timeline of how his interconnected universe unfolded:

The Life We Bury (2014)
Introduces college student Joe Talbert, his autistic brother Jeremy, and sets the foundation for the entire universe. Detective Max Rupert also makes his first appearance here.
The Guise of Another (2015)
Shifts the spotlight to Max Rupert’s brother, Alexander, as an insurance fraud case spirals into dangerous identity theft.
The Heavens May Fall (2016)
A massive crossover point. Detective Max Rupert investigates a murder case while defense attorney Boady Sanden represents the prime suspect.
The Deep Dark Descending (2017)
A harrowing, critically acclaimed turning point that follows Max Rupert to the frozen northern borders of Minnesota on a deeply personal quest for revenge.
The Shadows We Hide (2018)
We return to Joe Talbert from book one as he investigates the sudden death of the father he never really knew.
Nothing More Dangerous (2019)
A gorgeous, award-winning coming-of-age prequel that leaps back to the 1970s to explore the teenage years of attorney Boady Sanden growing up in rural Missouri.
The Stolen Hours (2021)
Focuses on Lila Nash (Joe Talbert’s girlfriend from the early books) as she fights to prove herself in the prosecutor’s office while tracking a serial predator.
Forsaken Country (2022)
Max Rupert returns! Now a broken man living off the grid, he is pulled back into the world when a friend’s daughter and grandson vanish into the wilderness.
Saving Emma (2023)
Boady Sanden takes center stage again as an old friend is accused of a terrible crime, forcing Boady to risk everything to protect a young girl.
The Quiet Librarian (2025)
His latest masterwork. A brilliant standalone suspense novel that follows Hana Babić, a woman who journeyed from being a farm girl to a war refugee in Bosnia, eventually settling as a librarian in Minnesota before her past catches up with her.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Exploring the Sub-Arcs: For the Picky Reader

If you don’t want to commit to the entire ten-book timeline right away and prefer to follow a specific character from start to finish, you can split his universe into three distinct mini-series:

The Detective Max Rupert Track

This is the darkest, most emotionally intense thread in Eskens’ work. It follows a good detective who slowly gets torn apart by grief over his wife’s unsolved death, eventually testing the limits of his own morality.

The Life We Bury ➔ The Guise of Another ➔ The Heavens May Fall ➔ The Deep Dark Descending ➔ Forsaken Country

The Joe Talbert & Lila Nash Track

Perfect for readers who love high-stakes courtroom tension, investigative journalism, and deep family loyalty.

The Life We Bury ➔ The Shadows We Hide ➔ The Stolen Hours

The Boady Sanden Track

A beautiful blend of historical coming-of-age mystery and modern legal defense dramas.

Nothing More Dangerous (The 1970s Prequel) ➔ The Heavens May Fall ➔ Saving Emma

A Peek Inside the Author’s Legal Notebook

What gives Eskens such undeniable EEAT (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) on the page is his own background. Before he ever published a single word, he spent twenty-five years working as a criminal defense attorney in Minnesota.

He didn’t just research how police interrogation rooms look or how a defense attorney structures a closing cross-examination; he lived it. He knows exactly how the legal system grinds down everyday people, and he brings that gritty, realistic accuracy into every courtroom scene.

His debut novel, The Life We Bury, was a massive word-of-mouth hit that earned him a Barry Award and a nomination for the prestigious Edgar Award. Since then, he has consistently racked up awards, establishing himself as a modern master of the midwestern mystery scene.

The Final Verdict

If you want to experience Allen Eskens at his absolute best, do not jump straight into his newer releases. Start precisely where it all began with The Life We Bury.

Watching these characters drift into each other’s lives across a decade of publishing history is incredibly rewarding. It turns a standard reading session into a trip back to a small town where you know everyone’s secrets, their flaws, and their redemption arcs. Grab a hot drink, lock your doors, and get ready to lose yourself in one of the finest interconnected mystery universes running today.

Know Your Author

Emon Anam

Hi, I’m Emon
I’m the voice and heart behind Whimsy Read. After nine years in the world of banking, I followed my passion for storytelling into the world of SEO and content strategy. Now, I blend that analytical eye with a deep love for literature to bring you book reviews that are thoughtful, honest, and always focused on the stories that stay with you.
When I’m not reading or writing, you’ll find me enjoying joyful chaos with my wife and three kids, getting lost in a new series, or revisiting my old loves: theater, music, and gaming. At the end of the day, I believe great books are meant to be shared, and I’m so glad you’re here to share them with me.